Miller & Son

By Asher Jelinsky | Drama
A transwoman mechanic tries to express herself at her family's auto shop.

Ryan works in the family-run auto shop, following in the tradition of becoming a mechanic just like Dad. Ryan is talented at the craft of auto repair, with an ease and fluency with the ins and outs of engines. But only when she’s not at work can Ryan tap into a whole other side of her identity, a femininity that feels just as essential to her self as her work.

But the careful architecture of Ryan’s life comes crashing down during one night out, and the partitions between Ryan’s different lives are breached. The balance skews Ryan’s life, challenging her sense of safety and perhaps changing her relationship in the family and the business.

Writer-director Asher Jelinsky’s stunningly observant drama features a trans character in the lead role, but the narrative is less about gender identity and more about the way we all compartmentalize aspects of ourselves — and how that compartmentalization doesn’t necessarily lead to a sense of wholeness and integration, but instead a fragmentation that gnaws away at a person’s inner equilibrium when it comes apart.

The film’s visuals captures Ryan’s central dilemma, showing the two parts of her life with distinct approaches. The daytime auto shop is shot with a more narrow aspect ratio, with gritty muted colors, lending those segments a washed-out, constrained feel. But Ryan’s nighttime life is full of pulsating music, color and a wider compositional eye, and it feels full of possibility, liberation and pleasure.

What links the two approaches are the excellent craftsmanship, from the pared-down, psychologically astute writing, the deft pacing that’s driven by Ryan’s internal arc and the intimate, precise directing that never loses sight of Ryan’s emerging dilemma, or the way that a shared glance of recognition becomes a huge crisis in a life governed by compartmentalization.

The other common factor is a fantastic central performance by Jesse James Keitel as Ryan. Full of undeniable screen presence and a kind of emotional luminosity, Keitel captures every unspoken, flickering nuance of Ryan with subtlety and precision. They capture a certain watchful recessiveness central to a character that can’t fully express herself in all aspects of her life and must always remain observant, calibrating self-expression with every changing context. This quality co-exists beautifully with an easeful confidence and competency at work. Keitel’s ability to play multiple levels of thought and emotion becomes useful as the film edges into its final movement, generating a suspense and tension that is quietly unbearable for both Ryan and the audience, as we wonder what the consequences are when competing “lives” collide.

Longlisted for the best live action short Oscar as a winner of a Student Academy Award, “Miller & Son” could easily veer into one direction, but instead it segues into a different, quieter grace note of an ending. It’s poignant and painful in a much more softly-spoken way, but the emotional tenor is more truthful to the film’s deeply psychological exploration of identity and segmentation.

The narrative travels a deeper, more resonant emotional journey than expected, and though the words exchanged in the final scene are few, they will knife at the collective heart of the audience with their terribly human longing and yearning. We all want to be seen, heard and understood for who we truly are; we all want to belong and be assured of being loved. But what price do we pay in our attempts to reconcile two sometimes heartbreakingly opposing needs? The film has no certain answers, but its emotional impact makes such questions linger long after the final haunting images.




You Might Also Like:

November 1st

By Charlie Manton | Drama
A mother goes to witness the execution of her son's murderer.

The Landing

By Josh Tanner | Sci-Fi
A man uncovers the horrifying truth of what landed on his childhood farm.

Sometimes, I Think About Dying (Sundance)

By Stefanie Abel Horowitz | Drama
A depressed woman thinks about dying. But a co-worker asks her out.

Bless Me Father

By Paul M. Horan | Drama
A priest has a moral dilemma when a man confesses a secret that affects his life.

The Goodnight Show

By Charlie Schwan | Sci-Fi
A virgin tries to get laid before an unstoppable asteroid ends the world.

Naysayer ft. Steven Yeun

By David M. Helman | Drama
A young father who is cut off from his son takes matters into his own hands.

Mordechai

By Benjamin Bee | Drama
An ultra-Orthodox Jew reunites with his twin brother for their father's funeral.

Retouch

By Kaveh Mazaheri | Drama
An Iranian woman's husband has an accident at home... and she just watches him die.

Stealing Silver ft. Maisie Williams

By Mark Lobatto | Drama
A woman uncovers the truth about the man living across from her.

Joseph’s Reel

By Michael Lavers | Romance
An elderly man is given the opportunity to relive one day of his life.

Cradle (The Oscars)

By Devon Manney | Animation
A veteran soldier battles phantom pains and memories of a pre-war life.

Don’t Be a Hero (Sundance)

By Pete Lee | Drama
A woman robs banks as a cowboy on her lunch break.

Our Kind of Love

By Elham Ehsas and Azeem Bhati | Romance
An Afghan village girl goes on her first date in London.

Lost & Found (The Oscars)

By Andrew Goldsmith and Bradley Slabe | Animation
A crochet dinosaur must unravel itself to save the love of its life.

Edmund the Magnificent ft. David Bradley & Ian McKellen

By Ben Ockrent | Comedy
A farmer invests his savings in a piglet.



Your favorite short films you haven't seen yet.

Inspiring and insightful. Entertaining and enlightening.
That's what you can expect here: no fluff. Just a steady
stream of the best films delivered to your inbox.